Nine errors worth catching before a freight bill is paid, the files that show each one, and how to check them without sending your bills to anyone.
A freight bill audit compares each carrier invoice with what you agreed to pay: the contract or tariff, the fuel table, the accessorial schedule and the shipment that actually moved. Outside audit firms usually take a share of what they recover. You can also run the same comparisons in-house, because every one of them is a rule applied to files you already have.
You need three kinds of export: the invoices (EDI 210 files, a carrier portal download or your TMS freight bill report), the shipments (your TMS or ERP shipment list with weights, class and dates), and the rates (the contract, the fuel table and the accessorial list).
| Check | What goes wrong | What to compare |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Duplicates | The same shipment billed twice: a re-sent invoice, a new invoice number or a corrected bill paid alongside the original. | PRO or tracking number, ship date, amount, across months and years. |
| 2. Base rate | A rate that is not the contract rate for that lane, weight break or service. | Invoice line rate against the contract for the lane and date. |
| 3. Fuel surcharge | Fuel worked out from the wrong week, the wrong index or the wrong table row. | The fuel table you agreed and the index price for the ship date. |
| 4. Accessorials | Liftgate, residential, inside delivery, detention or notification fees that were not ordered, not proven or above the agreed amount. | The accessorial list, the order and the proof of delivery. |
| 5. Detention | Waiting time billed past the free time, or with no arrival and departure times behind it. | Check-in and check-out times against the free time in the contract. |
| 6. Reweigh and reclass | LTL weight or freight class changed after pickup, raising the charge. | Shipped weight and class against the corrected bill and the inspection record. |
| 7. Parcel adjustments | Address corrections, dimensional weight and residential fees added after the label was printed. | Label data against the carrier's adjustment file. |
| 8. Proof of delivery | Paying for a delivery with no proof, or a damaged or short delivery that should become a claim. | POD status and exceptions for every paid bill. |
| 9. Accrual | Freight that moved but was not billed yet, left out of the month-end close. | Shipped and not yet invoiced, by cost center. |
Carriers set time limits for disputes in their contracts and tariffs, so the checks are worth running every week, not once a year.
Fairhaul is thirty open-source checks for shippers, brokers and carriers, including truckload, LTL, parcel, ocean and air bill audit, detention, fuel, reweighs, duplicates, proof of delivery and the freight accrual. Each check is plain code that applies written rules to your exports, on your computer. It writes the worklist and the dispute drafts. It does not pay a carrier or send anything. The accuracy measured on planted test files is on the product page.
The software is free under the MIT licence. The paid work is a fixed-price setup, from $6,500 for one close or one carrier book, agreed in writing before work starts. See the sample freight bill audit report, written by the check on made-up files.
Twenty minutes, no file on the first call. Tell us your TMS and carriers and we name the exports and the price.